Hmm, why do I keep talking about social issues these few days? Must be on some kind of “social issues” streak.
Anyway, today’s headline on CNA that read “MND announces another 10 temporary dorm sites for foreign workers” reminded me about the big hoohah surrounding the proposed building of a large foreign workers’ dorm at Serangoon Gardens a few months ago (see here).
I think the basic Singaporean mentality can be summed up as such: “I have absolutely nothing against foreign workers…just as long as I don’t come into contact with any of them. And I’m totally fine with foreign worker dorms being built in Singapore…just as long as they are not built near to where I live.”
Y’know, it’s easy to just dismiss this Serangoon Gardens issue and say “Aiyah…why the fuss? It’s just a dorm only mah! What’s the big deal?”
But my question to you would then be: So what happens if they build one next to YOUR house?
I would call this a very tricky issue, because if you were to ask me whether I am totally OK with having a large foreign worker dorm being built next to my house, I would hesitate to give you a straight “yes”.
Now I’ve had small foreign worker quarters being built literally next to my house before, and for a number of years in fact…due to an ongoing project just next to my house a few years back. And I can say for sure that there were more cons than pros pertaining to the fact that these little quarters were next to where I lived.
Just to name a few things: Rampant littering, noise pollution, and the occassional fist-fight (internally). I’ve seen and heard them all.
Yes, I would be lying if I said that I wasn’t irritated by all these actions. But I felt that it was by no means a justification for me to harbour any discriminatory attitudes towards them because of their race or nationality.
I wouldn’t be so quick to label all the angry Serangoon Gardens residents as “racists”. Some of them certainly have valid concerns, e.g. security, social problems, overcrowding.
But on the other hand, I would say that one should not view foreign workers in a negative or discriminatory manner. They are still human beings - fellow members of the human race, and they are here in Singapore to work for their livelihood…and we should ultimately treat all people with respect regardless of race or religion.
From the tone and questions of the residents, I believe you can tell if the resident was being genuinely concerned or plain discriminatory.
Trust me, this won’t be an easy issue.
If one day a new foreign worker dorm would be built next to your house, let’s see how you would react!

